How to Build Better Low Volatility Equity Strategies  

Tips on how to Construct Higher Low Volatility Fairness Methods  


The Position of Low Volatility Methods in Funding Portfolios 

Low volatility fairness methods enchantment to buyers for a lot of causes. First, they assist preserve our portfolios invested in equities in periods of market turmoil. Second, when well-constructed, they typically exhibit larger risk-adjusted returns than their larger volatility counterparts.

Whereas normal surveys of low volatility methods present that they do certainly defend buyers from market-driven danger, what’s ceaselessly ignored is that these similar methods will be insufficiently diversified or danger managed. To that finish, we’ll look at the important elements of an efficient low volatility portfolio development course of. These parts allow the development of low volatility portfolios with extra diversification and considerably higher risk-adjusted returns than the usual low volatility technique.

Low Volatility Methods: Three Potential Drawbacks  

Low volatility shares can ship a premium over the long run. And whereas they might present each volatility discount and capital safety in bear markets relative to cap-weighted indices, not all low volatility methods accomplish this to the identical diploma. Certainly, many commercially obtainable low volatility methods endure from frequent drawbacks.

1. A Lack of Diversification

Inverse volatility and minimal variance optimization are two frequent methodologies in low volatility methods. In inverse volatility portfolios, a inventory’s portfolio weight is proportional to its danger. Such portfolios penalize excessive volatility shares and reward their low volatility counterparts. They can be extremely concentrated. The identical criticism applies to the minimal variance optimization method, which, with out numerous constraints, can even unduly chubby the portfolio in a number of shares.

2. Unfavourable Publicity to Different Rewarded Components

Worth, Momentum, Excessive Profitability, and Low Funding, specifically, are among the many components which have rewarded buyers through the years, however low volatility methods can underweight such components and represent a drag on the long-term danger adjusted efficiency.

3. Extra Danger by means of Sector and Regional Exposures

Low volatility portfolios could have persistent sector or regional exposures that may open them as much as undo macroeconomic dangers. 

A Higher Approach to Construct Low Volatility Portfolios 

There are a number of cures to those diversification- and risk-related challenges in low volatility portfolios. To deal with the surplus weighting difficulty, we will construct extra diversified low volatility portfolios by deciding on weights based mostly on a number of optimization frameworks and introducing sturdy weight constraints. Each mannequin has parameter estimation dangers as a result of its specific structure. By averaging throughout a number of fashions, we will cut back a lot of the mannequin danger that comes with counting on a single framework. As well as, with no appreciable quantity of at instances advert hoc constraints, similar to min-max weights on shares or sectors, a given mannequin could produce overly concentrated or in any other case insufficiently diversified portfolios. To deal with this difficulty, we use so-called norm weight constraints that keep away from focus higher than ad-hoc, sample-dependent constraints. (We additionally make use of principal element evaluation — PCA, a statistical method — to de-noise the covariance matrices with which we assemble our portfolios.)

One other option to handle diversification in a low volatility technique is to extend a portfolio’s issue depth. This measure, when utilized to a single inventory, is just the sum of particular person issue exposures, or betas, in a portfolio. So, if we’re deciding on shares for a low volatility portfolio, we desire these with excessive publicity to the low volatility issue, however we additionally wish to filter out shares with important unfavourable publicity to different rewarded components. By implementing such filtering, our low volatility shares could have, to the utmost diploma potential, constructive publicity to Worth, Momentum, and different rewarded components. Because of this, in environments the place the low volatility issue is underperforming, the opposite components could possibly “choose up the slack” and defend the portfolio from a few of the harm that the portfolio may incur with out such filtering.

Data Science Certificate Tile

Each rewarded fairness issue has publicity to macroeconomic components. Which issue hundreds on probably the most macroeconomic danger will rely, after all, on the macroeconomic atmosphere, or regime. Nation- or region-specific drivers clarify a lot of a portfolio’s macro danger, so we will mitigate that danger by developing portfolios which can be geographically impartial relative to a cap-weighted benchmark. As a result of macro dangers are additionally typically sector pushed, deciding on low volatility shares inside sectors can mitigate macro danger. Sectors are necessary concerns since low volatility methods can chubby particular sectors, similar to Utilities, which can be delicate to rate of interest and different types of danger.

By way of empirical outcomes, the exhibit beneath exhibits {that a} low volatility portfolio with issue depth filters delivers a major risk-adjusted return in contrast with each cap-weighted and normal low volatility indexes. This holds for each US and Developed Markets low volatility methods.


Low Volatility Fairness Technique Efficiency and Danger Measures 

US Statistics

21 June 2002 to
30 September 2023
(RI/USD) 
Cap-Weighted  Sturdy Low Volatility
Technique 
MSCI Minimal
Volatility
Annualized Returns  9.41%  9.85%  8.92%
Annualized Volatility 19.35% 15.81%  16.17%
Sharpe Ratio 0.42 0.54 0.47 
Most Drawdown 54.6% 43.0% 46.6%

Developed Market Statistics 

21 June 2002 to
30 September 2023
(RI/USD)
Cap-Weighted Sturdy Low Volatility
Technique
MSCI Minimal
Volatility
Annualized Returns 8.32%  9.45%  7.96% 
Annualized Volatility 16.16%  12.79%  12.09% 
Sharpe Ratio 0.43  0.63  0.55 
Most Drawdown 57.1%  45.6%  47.7% 

The method described above ends in considerably larger issue intensities for each US and Developed Market portfolios, as the next charts reveal.


Issue Depth in Low Volatility Fairness Methods 

US Issue Intensities 

21 June 2002 to
30 September 2023
(RI/USD)
Sturdy Low Volatility
Technique
MSCI Minimal
Volatility
Issue Depth (Int) 0.43  0.21 

Developed Market Issue Intensities 

21 June 2002 to
30 September 2023
(RI/USD) 
Sturdy Low Volatility
Technique
MSCI Minimal
Volatility
Issue Depth (Int)  0.47  0.25 

This strategy additionally reduces macro exposures throughout geographies because the tables beneath point out. 


Macro Exposures in Low Volatility Methods 

US Exposures

21 June 2002 to
30 September 2023
(RI/USD) 
Sturdy Low Volatility
Technique
MSCI Minimal
Volatility
Quick Charges  –1.23 –1.43
Time period Unfold  –3.16 –3.16
Default Unfold  1.35 1.41
Breakeven Inflation  –3.75 –4.17

Developed Market Exposures

21 June 2002 to
30 September 2023
(RI/USD)
Sturdy Low Volatility
Technique
MSCI Min Vol
Quick Charges –1.21 –1.95
Time period Unfold –3.17 –4.00
Default Unfold 1.62 2.28
Breakeven Inflation –4.21 –6.04
Ad for CFA Institute Research and Policy Center

Conclusion 

Low volatility fairness portfolios will be useful additions to investor portfolios. They permit asset house owners to remain invested in equities even amid market turmoil. Nonetheless, not all low volatility methods are created equal. Many lack the diversification and danger management wanted to protect towards focus and macro danger.

To that finish, the funding course of outlined right here applies numerous measures to make sure the requisite degree of danger management. Of the 2 strategies highlighted, the primary mitigates focus danger by means of mannequin averaging, and the second applies a filter to weed out low issue depth shares.

By deploying these two strategies, whereas looking for regional and sectoral danger, we will increase diversification and cut back dangers within the portfolio by means of totally different market and macro environments relative to straightforward low volatility benchmarks. 

In the event you preferred this put up, don’t overlook to subscribe to Enterprising Investor and the CFA Institute Analysis and Coverage Middle.


All posts are the opinion of the creator. As such, they shouldn’t be construed as funding recommendation, nor do the opinions expressed essentially replicate the views of CFA Institute or the creator’s employer.

Picture credit score: ©Getty Photos / SimpleImages


Skilled Studying for CFA Institute Members

CFA Institute members are empowered to self-determine and self-report skilled studying (PL) credit earned, together with content material on Enterprising Investor. Members can file credit simply utilizing their on-line PL tracker.



Supply hyperlink